S4: Day 143 (1239)

May. 23rd, 2026 09:12 am
jillysriser: (purple)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I did a small bit of editing last night. Today I am going to do more as well as some things around the house. Everyone is sick/recovering from being sick. Everyone except for me, that is. I'm not sure how this will impact my ability to create. I did obtain some more tools to use in the creation process that I'm excited to test out at a later date.

For now, I am editing.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Concrete Genie".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

(no subject)

May. 22nd, 2026 05:26 pm
yuuago: (Germany - Reading)
[personal profile] yuuago
Witch Hat Atelier has been all over my tumblr dash lately. The art is really pretty and some of my friends are very into it. I kind of want to read the manga, but I would have to get it through interlibrary loan. HMM. What do you all think?

Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 8


Should I go to the trouble of ILLing it?

View Answers

Yes!
6 (75.0%)

No
0 (0.0%)

IDK/See results
2 (25.0%)

(no subject)

May. 22nd, 2026 05:12 pm
skygiants: Sheska from Fullmetal Alchemist with her head on a pile of books (ded from book)
[personal profile] skygiants
So the Boston Immigrant Justice Accompaniment Network, where I volunteer, is scraping the bottom of their bond fund. If you have a few pennies to toss, now would be a really exceptional time.

(I personally have been scratching my head trying to figure out what kind of best talent show this town has ever seen might be helpful to the overall cause, so I guess if there's anything you've ever wanted to see me do or post about particularly that might work as a fundraising incentive, let me know???)

S4: Day 142 (1238)

May. 22nd, 2026 07:19 am
jillysriser: (purple)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I did editing yesterday! Go me. Feels good. I intended to only do about five chapters, and I doubled that number. The edit isn't a tough one, either, so that's very nice. It's still a hot mess, but it's a hot mess that doesn't feel overwhelming. I do see that I need to reformat and redesign covers, however. I should pull the old version offline from selling, though.

Anyway, today is going to be more editing. I might try handwriting at some point as well, but we'll see how my body is feeling after the day job. I've been getting sore after working, and it's been taking more time than I want to admit to recover from that pain.

I'm slowly getting my summer plans together. I'm cautiously optimistic.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Concrete Genie".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

S4: Day 141 (1237)

May. 21st, 2026 07:46 am
jillysriser: (angry)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I took the full day off yesterday, like scheduled. It definitely left me feeling a lot better mentally. Today, I start doing some work again, and then I also catch up on chores that have been partially neglected. I do feel ready to press forward. I am definitely tired, though.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Concrete Genie".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

(no subject)

May. 20th, 2026 08:25 pm
skygiants: clone helmet lit by the vastness of space (clone feelings)
[personal profile] skygiants
So I read the Matthew Stover Revenge of the Sith novelization ---

[personal profile] portico: why
me: i don't have to justify myself

-- but the actual reason is that I didn't want to listen to the A More Civilized Age podcast episodes about it without having read it myself to form my own opinions first, and the approximately eleven hours they spend talking about it gives me two full weeks of podcast time to fill my walk to work. Also I'd heard from a couple different people that it was unexpectedly good!

With affectionate respect to the people who told me this, I did not actually find this to be true. In fact I found the book somewhat worse than I expected. However, it is unexpectedly gay, and I do understand how people can substitute the one thing for the other. If you care about Anakin and Obi-Wan, let me tell you, you are in luck, so does Matthew Stover. If you care about Anakin and Padme -- scratch that. If you care about Padme in any capacity, you are less in luck. This is the most boring I Care About Nothing But Being A Love Interest Padme Amidala that I've ever seen and that includes the Padme in the film, where Natalie Portman is at least attemptiong to project 'I'm trapped in this narrative get me out of here' with her eyes. My frustrations here are exacerbated by having relatively recently read the Mon Mothma book that succeeded (to my mind) in making Mon Mothma a complex and compelling political figure who is often kind of a failure. I would love to see a Padme who's a complex and compelling failure of a political figure, which is the way I think she often comes across in the Clone Wars TV show ... not necessarily on purpose .... but someone could write her that way on purpose ...

But, on the other hand, I had no real reason to expect the Revenge of the Sith novelization could or should be political thriller; this is a book that is 50% fight scene by volume. Indeed the first 30% of the book is One Long Action Sequence. My understanding is that this is because the original script, from which Matthew Stover was working, is also 30% one long action sequence that got cut down to five minutes in the actual film. I'm sorry but this IS very funny, I sympathize deeply with this poor man desperately trying to pad out a lightsaber fight to fill three chapters with extensive discussion of forms like it's the duel in The Princess Bride, only to get to the first screening and go 'god damn it!'

Anyway. It's fine. If they tell you it's a critical text in the Star Wars universe I think you might want to take that with some grains of salt, but then again, I think the most critical text in the Star Wars universe is Star Wars: The Bad Batch: Season Two Episode Three: The Solitary Clone so you might want to take anything I say with some grains of salt. But do you want a page of Obi-Wan thinking about Anakin's ass? This book will indeed give that to you.

S4: Day 140 (1236)

May. 20th, 2026 06:54 am
jillysriser: (Default)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I came back from the day job in a lot of pain, so I chose to take care of my body. I did some shopping as well at the mall. Lots of little things for the house and for me.

Today is creative rest day. Feels like I've had a lot of them in general, however, I desperately want to stay on schedule. I will honor the day. I will keep the schedule. My body and my brain need the break still anyway.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Concrete Genie".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

S4: Day 139 (1235)

May. 19th, 2026 07:49 am
jillysriser: (angry)
[personal profile] jillysriser
Another small dab of editing yesterday. I'm struggling a bit with energy and motivation. Most of it is attributed to it being the end of the day job season, I think. I'm trying to not worry too much over my lack of creativity. Per usual, I am my own worst enemy.

Today is a new day, and I need to remember this is all temporary. Eleven more days of the day job and then I'll be free for a while.


Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Concrete Genie".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

S4: Day 138 (1234)

May. 18th, 2026 07:34 am
jillysriser: (Default)
[personal profile] jillysriser
Did a small amount of editing. Mostly I just got work done around the house.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Another Crab's Treasure".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.
rigormorphis: Xavin from Runaways (Default)
[personal profile] rigormorphis

I finished reading this book a few weeks ago, and due to my goldfish memory, I'm already forgetting details. I figured I should type out my thoughts before even more of them escape me.

When I'm Gone, Look for Me in the East is told through the eyes of Chuluun, a novice monk from Mongolia who has been tasked with locating a tulku. To complete this mission, he must reunite with his estranged twin brother, Mun, who was himself identified as a tulku at the age of eight...and who later renounced Buddhism and left the monastery to forge his own life in the city. Mun is reluctant to subject another child to the same fate he feels was forced upon him, Chuluun is stung by the wedge Mun drove between them by leaving, and matters are only made more complicated by the fact that Mun and Chuluun can hear each other's thoughts.

My overall impression is that it had the makings of a book I could have really loved, but unfortunately, it kept getting in its own way.

To be clear, there were a lot of things I liked. Chuluun is an intriguing and sympathetic narrator, for one. He is a novice who will soon undergo the rites to become a full monk, and he strives to embody Buddhist principles even as he fears that he is insufficient in his learning. Because time is an illusion and, as Chuluun tells us repeatedly, there is only the here and now, the entire novel is narrated in present tense, by which I mean that present is nearly the only tense that is ever used. (Having returned the book to the library, I don't have an illustrative quote on hand, but here's one from another review I found online: "To my eye Little Bat looks even more tranquil now than he does an hour ago...") Between this and We Ride Upon Sticks, it seems Barry is an author who enjoys experimenting with point of view, and I enjoyed the fruits of her experimentation in both books. Throughout, Chuluun also struggles with the inherent paradox of desiring to become someone who is free of desire. A juicy theme!

The sibling relationship was also very compelling to me. There are years of resentment and pain and love piled up between Chuluun and Mun. While they never had an easy or straightforward relationship, they were set firmly on different paths from age eight, when Mun was identified as the fifth reincarnation of a lama and they were taken to live in a monastery. Mun became the Redeemer Who Sounds the Conch in the Darkness, Chuluun the Servant of the Redeemer Who Sounds the Conch in the Darkness. Where Chuluun experienced the austerity of monastic life as a sort of paring down to his essence, Mun experienced it as a prison that was trying to rob him of who he was. Mun left, and Chuluun stayed. Barry gives equal weight to both of their perspectives, allows them to be right and wrong in equal measure. Even with the mind-link and the larger-than-life destiny that was assigned to one of them, they feel convincingly like siblings who can't figure out how to cross the chasm between them. I always want to read about that sort of thing.

The trouble is that for all that I found the themes, characters, and dynamics compelling, the book was continually slamming pause on all of that to deliver lectures about Mongolian history and culture. It was well meant, certainly, but disastrously clunky. Barry—who, I should note here for context, is Vietnamese American, not Mongolian herself—wanted to make incredibly, perfectly, excruciatingly certain that you knew she did her research, even though this fact is presumably also demonstrated by the bibliography she included at the end of the novel. And I have no problem with that on the face of it, I know sweet fuck all about Mongolian history and culture and am delighted to be educated, but my god, Chuluun was not the right narrator to be turning to the camera and giving me history lessons every other page. I do have an illustrative quote for this, because while I was reading I posted a passage on mastodon out of sheer exasperation: cut for length of passage )

Chuluun is Mongolian, he has always lived in Mongolia, and he's been living as a monk for years. Why would he be consciously thinking of the simple facts of his life in this way? This is also not important context for anything that happens, so there is truly no reason for us to have been transported mid-scene into a textbook. And it isn't just this one scene—this happens roughly once every two pages. At one point Chuluun starts telling the reader that Monoglian is one of the world's oldest surviving languages, and there is no reason for him to be thinking about this, because all that's happening is that he's having a conversation with his brother in the language they both speak. It took me a million years to get through this relatively short book because momentum was never allowed to build. I get that Barry wanted her English-speaking audience to understand what she was talking about, but this is absurd!

Throughout the entire book, I found myself wishing Barry had committed to telling one or the other: either a story in which an omnisicient third-person narrator delivers Victor Hugo-esque digressions meant for the audience's education, or a story with a tight first-person narrator who leaves the audience to wonder about some things or look them up later. Instead she tried to have the best of both worlds, and it didn't work. It's a shame, because I think I could have really loved either of those other books.

(no subject)

May. 17th, 2026 11:02 pm
yuuago: (DenNor - Chess)
[personal profile] yuuago
+ Been super busy lately! Not with anything in particular, mind you, just odds and ends.

+ Took Friday off. Very glad I did. It's nice to have a 4-day weekend (Monday is a stat).

+ Managed to finish the draft for the fic I'm working on for Crack the WIP! ...Still need to do a lot of work mind you, but The End Is In Sight. For a while there I was totally hating this fic, but after putting it away for a month I'm at the "huh, it's not that bad" stage.

+ Worked on my FTH fic today. Not sure when it'll get finished but it's moving along. I'm starting to hope that Pru is becoming easier for me to write. If this story works out (which, well, it has to, because FTH) then I might, at some point, be able to finish the other fics I started with him and never finished. Until this point, he has always defeated me, that obnoxious bastard.

S4: Day 137 (1233)

May. 17th, 2026 09:51 am
jillysriser: (Default)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I made a lot of plot cards yesterday. I have a rough idea of where the book is going, though I'm still not quite sure how it's all going to work. It's a start.

Today I'm going to edit, but I also want to try writing again. I'm feeling the urge. I'm almost on break with the day job, too. I'm cautiously optimistic about this summer.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Another Crab's Treasure".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

S4: Day 136 (1232)

May. 16th, 2026 09:49 am
jillysriser: (heart)
[personal profile] jillysriser
The hope is to organize my plot notes today. I'd like to do some editing as well. Words will be the last thing I do, as lately, I've been too tired to create that stream of flow from my brain.

In a dream world, today will refresh me mentally. It's my day to myself, and I haven't had one of those in a long, long time.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Another Crab's Treasure".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook. "Pachinko" audio.

S4: Day 135 (1231)

May. 15th, 2026 09:47 am
jillysriser: (heart)
[personal profile] jillysriser
Too tired to think.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Another Crab's Treasure".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook.

(no subject)

May. 16th, 2026 07:53 am
skygiants: Mae West (model lady)
[personal profile] skygiants
I do think there is a particular charm, a particular interest, in a biographer who is really visibly in love with their subject. Like, you probably wouldn't want it in every biography. But it's nice to know that the author really extremely wants to be there. It gives an enjoyable sort of tension to the reading experience: at what point is the book going to go off-the-rails because the author has spontaneously transmigrated back to 1931 in a doomed attempt to alter the course of history and fix Buster Keaton's Hollywood career with the power of her passion alone? It could happen! It feels like everything has been foreshadowing it!

Obviously Camera Man: Buster Keaton, the Dawn of Cinema, and the Invention of the of the Twentieth Century does not in fact go off the rails in this way, it does actually remain an interesting and readable biography that uses Keaton's life and career as a jumping-off point to explore the times in which he lived. In the book's introduction, Stevens explains that her fascination with Keaton is such that whenever I heard about something that took place between 1895 and 1966, I found myself trying to fit that event or phenomenon into the puzzle of his life and work. (She also uses the introduction to share a poem she wrote about Keaton. It's not bad!) Anyway, this is a pretty fruitful methodology that leads her to down various side paths to explore not just the history of early cinema but other twentieth-century touchstones such as changing child labor laws, vaudeville and minstrel shows, the rise of Alcoholics' Anonymous, and the career of F. Scott Fitzgerald.*

Often these aren't things that directly impacted Keaton -- Keaton never participated in AA, for example; by the time the program started to gain popularity, Keaton had already hit his rock bottom and come out the other side -- but they run along parallel tracks, such that Keaton's life casts a mirror on the phenomenon or vice versa, or there's an interesting alternate pathway to be imagined where they did indeed intersect. Keaton and Chaplin only worked together once, but you can't help but compare/contrast their trajectories; Keaton and Fitzgerald may never even have met at all, but the downward arcs of their careers were both intertwined with MGM executive Irving Thalberg, on whom Fitzgerald based his last novel.

(Also, it can't have helped with Fitzgerald's fascination, says Stevens, that Thalberg was also extraordinarily good-looking, slight-framed and serious-faced, with large, liquid brown eyes and wavy black hair -- an appearance not unlike that of a certain slapstick comedian whose contract his company had just acquired. We DON'T know they met but we DO know that if they did, Fitzgerald would CERTAINLY have thought Keaton was hot!)

It feels, in other words, like exactly what it is -- a book written by a person whose obsession with one individual has led them down a number of other interesting rabbitholes, to fruitful if not entirely cohesive results. If Keaton had been a fictional character, this might have been a 120K fanfic with a number of beautifully researched, oddly specific chapters. Because Keaton is a real person, we got this book. I had a great time!

S4: Day 134 (1230)

May. 14th, 2026 07:26 am
jillysriser: (heart)
[personal profile] jillysriser
Refreshed. Today is about house renewal and editing/plotting.

Keeping it simple for the time being. I feel behind on regular life responsibilities at the moment. Need to fix that first.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook.

S4: Day 133 (1229)

May. 13th, 2026 07:15 am
jillysriser: (fire)
[personal profile] jillysriser
Home from the day job today which means I'm going to struggle with things to do most of the day, at least beyond chores. In a dream world, I will do some editing and some plotting. Wednesday is usually my day of creative rest, and I would like to honor my schedule even if it's been thrown off a lot recently.


Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Cat Quest II".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook.
shadaras: A phoenix with wings fully outspread, holidng a rose and an arrow in its talons. (Default)
[personal profile] shadaras
mm, some things:

1.
Earlier this evening I wandered across the street to pick up a few things for dinner and ended up spending a good five minutes or so chatting with the queers canvassing for ballot propositions, because it's very easy to catch me with one about park funding, especially when they look like a pair of lesbians, which it turned out they indeed are. Apparently they recently moved to the area (one of them coming back, the other to stay with their partner).

Shall see if I run into them again, but they said I should check out the gaming place (when asked "what kind of gaming" I was informed "most kinds!", because despite the on-the-face marketing being minigolf it in fact also has board games and video games and would be cool with people playing ttrpgs there) in the next town over (where they live), so, it's quite possible! This area is, uh. Very small in some ways. (But, as they pointed out when talking about why they came here, generally quite safe for queer people in a way that the more southern state they moved from wasn't necessarily.)


2.
Today is a day where I feel like a person, and mostly that throws into relief how many days I do not, and I find this deeply frustrating but mostly in a "idk if there's much I can do about that?" way. It's very... look when the main problems are fatigue and brain fog, that's not stuff that people tend to have particularly helpful suggestions for?


3.
Slowly catching up on a Star Wars podcast (A More Civilized Age), and at one point the hosts got sidetracked talking about how holocrons (especially sith holocrons) are like AI chatbots, and I cannot get that comparison out of my head. It makes sense and it's hilarious, and also yup sure is a sith vibe.


4.
I mentioned watching the first bit of Maul: Shadow Lord here, and I finished it last week (the final episodes of s1 aired on May 4th, of course). It's very... well, obviously the whole thing needs to be full of set-up/lore for the greater universe, blah blah disney star wars blah blah. But the final two episodes in particular were just "yup, here's the disney playbook".

Read more... )

Like, I'll watch s2 when it comes out because the animation is great and I enjoy Maul interacting with an apprentice and also girls/women with complicated relationships to lightside/darkside matters. But also, it's a show aimed at people who wanna see cool fights and I keep going BUT WHAT IF YOU HAD CONVERSATIONS AND THEMES. xD I am not the target audience, I know that, it's fine.


5.
I also somehow continue to keep up with Critical Role s4: Araman! It is enjoyable! I adored ep24, which was like 5hrs of talking and roleplaying and scheming with zero combat. I had way more fun than I was expecting with ep25, which was three straight hours of combat with the party that is mostly not statted for combat and who thus need to be CLEVER and STRATEGIC about what they're up to. If I gotta listen to D&D combat, I'd rather have it be the kind of combat where players are trying to figure out how to use unexpected skills and abilities to solve a puzzle that happens to be combat than one where the solution is "I roll to attack" 90% of the time.

(BLM going "holy shit I forgot you could do that, uhhhh, okay. I am about to tell you something that I did not think there is any way you could've learned in this combat, this is going to have MASSIVE implications going forward" to the Divination Wizard was genuinely a stand-out moment, and when he got to the reveal of "this is what you were supposed to think happened. this is what everyone else thinks happened. YOU know better, because you touched fate and saw through the facade." at the end it was extremely !!!. This is very hard to pull off in a combat-focused episode, and yet! Kudos to BLM and also Marisha for using her abilities in this way!)

anyway I'm particularly fond of the following PCs at the moment, though tbh I think the whole crew is fun to listen to:
- Hal: Mr Dad Man, whose brother's execution was the start of this whole campaign (orc bard)
- Thaisha: The Mom Friend, Except She's Actually A Mom, who was with Hal for a while (had a few kids together!) but then they split up (orc druid)
- Vaelus: what if you actually leaned into elves being very old and were also sad that your god got killed in the war (elven paladin)
- Murray: tired academic who grew up working-class and it shows (dwarf wizard)
- Kattigan: look sometimes the whole "my dog is my best friend" thing goes a long way when also you're sensible and kind (human ranger)

They just finished the first cycle of arcs, so they'll be drawing the whole crew back together soon. I am excited about this! I want the mixing of parties and seeing them all interact! Also it is going to be SO MANY PEOPLE and therefore a bit exhausting.


6.
Finally finished Max Gladstone's Dead Hand Rule, the penultimate novel in his Craft Wars series. It is very deeply a book about the contrast between being a person and a symbol, and what it means to bear great power, and what it means to choose between being yourself and a vessel for something greater, and also tbh rather much about how personal relationships shape national politics and how hard-and-yet-easy it is to allow yourself to love people.

v excited for seeing how he brings it to a conclusion because well he sure did end this novel by being like "the threat is here and realised and is a ticking time bomb, GOOD LUCK" at his protags. Very much "get your shit together and work together or DIE", tbh, which... okay a bunch of them are necromancers and some of them are therefore undead, so, like, death isn't the threat so much as the subsumption of existence into a colonizing force's clockwork wiles, which isn't great or what any of them want. So. It'll be fun to see them channel the power of gods and souls into a solution that hopefully doesn't blow the world up too much along the way.

Also perhaps I will actually read the entire Craft Sequence again, in chronological order (as opposed to publication order, because that's how I've read them as they release), before the final volume comes out. That'd be fun.

S4: Day 132 (1228)

May. 12th, 2026 07:38 am
jillysriser: (Default)
[personal profile] jillysriser
I'm in a planning zone. It's a good thing. I'm also getting so much good feedback to work with, which brings me one step closer to publication of some self-publishing project goals.

I need to embrace the planning zone further.

Currently:
Playing: "Final Fantasy VI". "Death Stranding". "Octopath Traveler: Zero". "Cat Quest II".
Reading: "The Witching Hour" audio. "The Drawing of Three" print. "Saga Collection 1" ebook.

(no subject)

May. 11th, 2026 08:36 pm
skygiants: Beatrice from Much Ado putting up her hand to stop Benedick talking (no more than reason)
[personal profile] skygiants
I don't know that Angela Thirlwell's Rosalind: A Biography of Shakespeare's Immortal Heroine was particularly mind-blowing for me as a text in terms of new knowledge or insights on As You Like It. However, it certainly was satisfying for me to read, in the way it is always satisfying to read a book with someone who passionately agrees with you about a mildly contrarian fannish opinion, like:

Angela Thirlwell: I simply think Rosalind is the absolute top-tier Shakespeare heroine
Me [nodding vigorously]: How true!
Angela Thirlwell: she is so witty and clever and in absolute total narrative control of her text and also doing gender like nobody else in Shakespeare
Me [nodding vigorously]: I think everyone who puts on an As You Like It should read your book!
Angela Thirwell: and As You Like It is a brilliant work that hangs together brilliantly in its entirety
Me [nodding en--pausing]: well I'm not sure I agree entirely with that
Angela Thirlwell: and here's my chapter on Rosalind's Daughters which includes every literary heroine I've ever loved. Elizabeth Bennet is kind of a Rosalind when you think about it.
Me [nodding politely]: I see, I see. Do you have any evidence for that?
Angela Thirlwell: Well, no. But! I believe it in my heart. Because Rosalind is the best!
Me [nodding vigorously]: She's the best!

The part that was probably most interesting for me in terms of actual new thoughts about Rosalind and As You Like It was the contextualization of the play in in terms of when, exactly, it was written, and what other plays it sits alongside in its canonical period, including some that are relatively unfamiliar to me -- I don't actually have a great constant sense in my head of Shakespeare's timeline (other than the obvious TEMPEST IS THE LAST) and the Great Chronological DWJ Project has made me much more interested in tracing the way a train of thought evolves over the course of somebody's work. It's interesting to see Rosalind and Viola as different ways of working out a concept that begins all the way back in Two Gentlemen of Verona; Thirlwell makes much of the fact that Viola is stressed and and serious and poetic whereas Rosalind is almost always speaking in comic prose, and takes charge of her own epilogue. Indeed she never forgets to remind us that Rosalind has the epilogue. You can tell what Thirlwell's favorite bits of the play are because she will quote them at least times in the text in order to prove five different points, blissfully unconcerned with repetition. I personally did not need to return quite so many times to the Bay of Portugal but I guess even the fact that Rosalind speaks the greatest percentage of her play of any Shakespeare heroine [good for her!] does not provide that many Rosalind lines to quote from.

Anyway. Do I think you ought to read this book if not for the pleasure of nodding vigorously along with various enthusiastic statements about Rosalind? Like, do I think it will transform you into a person who nods vigorously along with enthusiastic statements about Rosalind, if you were not one previously? Who could say! Report back if you find out!
Page generated May. 23rd, 2026 04:12 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios